Carlton lost to St Kilda by 13 points at Princes Park.

Round 2, 1914

Carlton 0.4 4 1.8 14 3.9 27 4.11 35
St Kilda 2.3 15 4.3 27 4.6 30 6.12 48
Venue: Princes Park Date: Saturday May 2, 1914
Result: Lost by 13 points Umpire: Leslie C. White Crowd: 25,000
Goalkickers: V.Gardiner 2, C.Fisher 1, J.Wells 1.
Best: B.Dick, G.Green, V.Valentine, A.McDonald, H.Haughton, G.Challis, C.Hammond, P.O'Brien, C.Fisher

Reports: P.O'Brien (Kicking) Guilty suspended.

Game Review

A crowd of 2,000 ruffians mob the umpire after Carlton lose to St Kilda by 13 points. The League has been called upon to give more protection to umpires. - 100 Years of Australian Rules Football.

In a hard fought match St. Kilda got the early break. The Blues' skipper Billy Dick kept the Saints crack forward McNamara quiet for most of the game. The visitors led by 13 points at half time, but the Blues hit back and got within 3 points at the last break. The Blues hit the front in the final quarter but McNamara scored 2 late goals and the Saints ran out winners by 13 points.


The Leader newspaper (May 09) writing about the crowd invasion and said of the fence; "The Carlton officials took no steps to prevent the disorderly element intruding on the arena, beyond erecting a new fence in place of the old rickety structure that used to do duty over 40 years ago in a different part of Princes Park. The new fence, judging by results, does not seem to be much of a barrier in checking larrikins instincts. What is really required is a trooper or two patrolling the ground, as the foot police are useless in a combined rush. The authorities, however, have learnt their lesson, and there should be no fear of recurrence of the unseemly disturbance."
The old fence referred to was the movable fence that was at the old ground called Princes Oval, near the University. This fence had to erected before every football season and removed and stored at season's end.

"The crowd of the day assembled at St. Kilda/(Carlton), some 25,000 barrackers, whose behaviour at the termination of the game was disgraceful. The umpire was brutally assaulted, and the ladies! did their little best to disable the players as they returned to the dressing rooms after the fray. The weapons used was the useful umbrella. It seems that players and umpires will have to be protected by the militia, and a subway built from the centre of the ground to the pavilion."
(Trove: Public Opinion May 07 1914, p21)

At the end of this round Carlton were in 7th spot on the ladder with a percentage of 87.5.


B: 4 Andy McDonald 15 Ernie Jamieson 10 Paddy O'Brien
HB: 2 Ted Brown 14 Billy Dick (c) 7 Steve Leehane
C: 8 Tom Clancy 25 Alf Baud 12 George Challis
HF: 17 Gordon Green 21 Charlie Fisher 26 George Calwell
F: 24 Charlie Hammond 1 Jack Wells 13 Vin Gardiner
Ruck: 5 Harry Haughton (vc) 3 Percy Daykin 6 Viv Valentine
Coach: Norman Clark

Possible names, if any one disagrees, please contact Blueseum.
Back Row L - R: Vin Gardiner, Charlie Hammond, Charlie Fisher, Steve Leehane, Alf Baud, Ernie Jamieson, Tom Clancy.
Centre Row: Jack Wells, Harry Haughton, Billy Dick, Paddy O'Brien, George Calwell, Gordon Green.
Front Row: George Challis, Andy McDonald, Viv Valentine, Ted Brown, Percy Daykin.
A. McDonald and V. Valentine are wearing the lace-up canvas jackets.
The trainer standing on our right is possibly Harry Sampson


Far left; Possibly Viv Valentine roving to the pack. Could be George Calwell running in


Images: Trove; The Leader May 09 p34. J. C. Bartlett jnr.


100 VFL Games: Billy Dick
Debut: Charlie Fisher and George Calwell

Round 1 | Round 3
Contributors to this page: blueycarlton , PatsFitztrick , Jarusa , Bombasheldon , camelboy , molsey , WillowBlue , kkk , true_blue24 , steve and admin .
Page last modified on Thursday 21 of May, 2020 12:59:34 AEST by blueycarlton.

Google Search

Random Image

1981 Grand Final - David Parkin addresses the players.
1998 Rd 17 - Whitnall bags 8 goals.

Online Users

135 online users