| Player | Seasons at Carlton | Seasons at Melbourne | Other Clubs |
| Ken McKaige | 1953 - 1954 | 1951 - 1952 | Nil |
| Graham Kerr | 1954 - 1955 | 1957 | Nil |
| Keith Robinson | 1956 | 1954 | Nil |
| Kevin Clarke | 1956 - 1959 | 1955 | Nil |
| John Comben | 1963 - 1966 | 1967 | Nil |
| Tony Thiessen | 1964 | 1963 | North Melbourne (1965) |
| Ron Barassi | 1965 - 1969 | 1953 - 1964 | Nil |
| Peter McLean | 1966 - 1968 | 1964 - 1965 | Nil |
| Ken Jungwirth | 1967 | 1966 | Nil |
| Peter Smith | 1968 - 1970 | 1966 - 1967 | Nil |
| Brent Crosswell | 1968 - 1975 | 1980 - 1982 | North Melbourne (1975 - 1979) |
| Phil Pinnell | 1969 - 1979 | 1980 - 1981 | Nil |
| Paul Hurst | 1970 - 1974 | 1975 - 1977 | Nil |
| Vin Catoggio | 1973 - 1980 | 1981 - 1982 | South Melbourne (1983) |
| Michael Young | 1977 - 1980 | 1981 - 1982 | Nil |
| Greg Wells | 1980 - 1982 | 1969 - 1980 | Nil |
| Peter Rohde | 1985 - 1987 | 1988 - 1995 | Nil |
| Paul Payne | 1989 | 1985 - 1988 | Nil |
| Earl Spalding | 1992 - 1997 | 1987 - 1991 | Nil |
| Andrew Leoncelli * | 1993 | 1996-2003 | Nil |
| Brent Heaver | 1992 - 1996 | 1990 - 1991 | Port Power (1997 - 1998) |
| James Cook | 1994 to 1995 | 2000 | Bulldogs (1996 - 1999) |
| Sean Charles | 1998 | 1992 - 1997 | St Kilda (2000 - 2001) |
| Troy Longmuir | 2005 - 2006 | 1998 - 1999 | At Fremantle (2000 - 2004) |
| Chris Johnson | 2009 - 2010 | 2005 - 2008 | N/A |
| Brock McLean | 2010 - 2014 | 2004 - 2009 | Nil |
| Tomas Bugg * | 2019 | 2016 - 2018 | GWS Giants 2012 - 2015 |
| Oscar McDonald | 2021 - 2022 | 2015 - 2020 | At Fremantle 2024 - ? |
NB * denotes players who did not, or are yet to, play a senior game at Carlton