Sectional Round 3, Carlton defeated Melbourne by 25 points at Princes Park.

Round 17, 1899

Carlton 1.0 6 2.0 12 6.3 39 6.5 41
Melbourne 0.1 1 0.2 2 0.2 2 2.4 16
Venue: Princes Park
Date: Saturday 9 September 1899
Result: Win by 25 Points
Goalkickers: B.Walsh 3, H.Thompson 2, B.Bird 1.
Umpire: Hood

Game Review

Due to the vagaries of the Sectional system, Carlton climbed to sixth place on the ladder after this shock win over Melbourne in the last game of the season. Playing the cohesive football that been glimpsed far too rarely throughout a troubled year, the Blues kept Melbourne almost scoreless for three quarters, and put victory beyond doubt with a four unanswered goals in the third term.

"The Redlegs were fairly out of the hunt with Carlton, who ran rings round them with general excellence. 'Dido' alias Considine, merits first place of the day, fast off the mark, quick as a terrier at ground play, and clever in the extreme in running and handballing. Of the rest Walsh, H. Thompson, Monagle, McShane, Stuckey, Williams and McNamara deserve special mention." (Melbourne Punch September 14 p24)

Therefore, the 1899 season ended with:
- Carlton's first victory in the "sectional" play-offs;
- The Blues first win over Melbourne; and
- our first victory over anyone other than St Kilda or South Melbourne.

Happily, the new century would soon produce much better results than had been attained thus far.


B: Bill Sharkey Arthur Thompson Peter Williams (vc)
HB: Will Stuckey (c) Ernie Walton Jack Gilbert
C: Wally O'Cock Henry McShane Bill Casey
HF: Bobby Walsh Bill McNamara Dick Walker
F: Victor Rapp Harry Thompson Bob Bird
Ruck: Bill Collins Pat Considine Billy Monagle
No Coach: No coach and the captain directed the side


In: J.Gilbert, V.Rapp
Out: G.Cowell, H.Evans


Debut: Jack Gilbert
Debut and Only Game: Victor Rapp
Last Game: Dick Walker, Billy Monagle, Harry Thompson
Score Records: This is Melbourne's lowest ever score against Carlton

Round 16 | 1900
Contributors to this page: Jarusa , blueycarlton , PatsFitztrick , Bombasheldon , camelboy , molsey , kkk , WillowBlue and admin .
Page last modified on Tuesday 31 of March, 2020 22:46:25 AEDT by Jarusa.

Google Search

Random Image

1999 GF - Seven's up Nelsons.
1996 Semi Final - Fraser Brown.

Online Users

379 online users