Carlton lost to Melbourne by 65 points at the MCG

Round 8, 1955

Carlton 1.2 8 5.6 36 7.11 53 9.16 70
Melbourne 2.7 19 8.11 59 14.13 97 20.15 135
Venue: MCG Date: Saturday June 4, 1955
Result: Loss by 65 points Umpire: Beitzel Crowd: 34,669
Goalkickers: N.O'Brien 5, P.Webster 2, D.Beasy 1, J.Mills 1.
Reports: Nil Injuries: Ellis (cramp) replaced by Paice at three quarter time. Crowe (knee) replaced by G. Kerr final quarter. Milroy (cork leg)

Game Review

The Blues took on the undefeated Melbourne, who it must be said were sitting bang in the middle of their 'golden era'. We were no match for the Demons who took the game by 65 points.

The Blues fell to 8th after this loss, with a percentage of 103.1.

"The Demons were too big and strong in the ruck, too clever and fast in roving, and too cool, calm and collected in defence."

The Blues made too many mistakes with short passing on the backline and let Melbourne in for a few easy goals. Wingers Laurie Kerr and John Sullivan beat their opponents on the day. Carlton fought back in the third quarter to get within 14 points, but the Demons put the foot down and extended the lead to 43 points at the last break. An indication of Melbourne's depth was that their top goal kicker Clarke was unavailable, so they brought in a young Laurie Mithen who kicked a cool 7.2! At the other end, Noel O'Brien scored 5.3 plus 2 shots that failed to score. "He moved nicely and kicked well." Legendary Melbourne coach Norm Smith; "Bobby (Nobby) O'Brien, Carlton full forward, did a great job for his side. He is the best full forward we have met this season."

Carlton coach Perc Bentley

"We lost because we could not match Melbourne in the ruck and roving divisions. Our chief trouble this year is our followers. We miss Ken Hands, our captain, in the ruck, and we want several more tall players. Unfortunately injury has kept young 6ft. 4in. Graham Donaldson out of the side. Ground conditions were against us. The ball was not greasy, but the turf was holding, and Melbourne was more accustomed to the conditions. I feel the scores do not give a true indication of the relative strength of the two teams. It must be remembered we finished with only 17 men. Bill Milroy, our acting captain and hardest worker in the ruck would have left the ground if we had not already used our 19th and 20th men."


Noel O'Brien, Laurie Kerr, Bill Milroy, Denis Zeunert, John Brown, Jack Sullivan, Bob Crowe.


N. O'Brien 5.3, P. Webster 2.2, J. Mills 1.1, D. Beasy 1.1, B. Milroy 0.2, J. Ellis 0.1, J. James 0.2, Kerr 0.3, J. Sullivan 0.1


B: 15 Bruce Comben 25 George Ferry 14 Vin English
HB: 16 John Brown 34 Bob Crowe 19 Denis Zeunert
C: 30 Jack Sullivan 10 John James 11 Laurie Kerr
HF: 8 Jack Ellis 3 Peter Webster 17 Doug Beasy
F: 24 Bernie Moran 26 Noel O'Brien 29 Peter Aitken
Ruck: 2 Bill Milroy (acting capt.) 4 Bob Bosustow 9 Jack Mills
Res: 33 John Paice 35 Graham Kerr
Coach: Percy Bentley

Round 7 | Round 9
Contributors to this page: WillowBlue , PatsFitztrick , Bombasheldon , blueycarlton , molsey , camelboy and admin .
Page last modified on Tuesday 22 of December, 2015 09:49:49 AEDT by WillowBlue.

Google Search

Random Image

1988 - Steve Da Rui.
1948 Rd 8 - No.12 Doug Williams.

Online Users

311 online users