| Player | Era | Other Points |
| Norman Clark | 1905 - 1912 | Via Stawell, Victoria |
| Les Gregory | 1944 - 1945 | Originally from Albury, NSW / Richmond 2nd's |
| Peter Turner | 1996 | Also played at the Adelaide Crows |
| Trent Sporn | 2002 - 2006 | Originally from Murrayville, Victoria |
| Rhys O'Keeffe | 2009 - 2013 | Drafted at the 2008 National Draft - Kilburn SA. |
| Matthew Wright | 2016 - 2018 | Originally from: Walkerville (SA) / Nth Adelaide (SANFL) / Adelaide Crows |
| Kym LeBois | 2017 - 2019 | Originally from: Koonibba (SA) |
| George Hewett | 2022 - ? | Originally from: Prince Alfred College (SA) |
NB * Denotes player did not, or is yet to play a game at senior level with Carlton.