Carlton lost to West Coast by 77 points - Subiaco.

Round 14, 2005

Carlton 6.3 39 8.6 54 8.7 55 9.8 62
West Coast 3.3 21 6.8 44 16.13 109 21.13 139
Venue: Subiaco Date: Saturday July 2, 2005
Result: Loss by 77 points Crowd: 39,928
Goalkickers: Fevola 4, Johnson 2, Camporeale, Lappin, Scotland 1
Umpires: Kennedy, Nicholls, Fraser Injuries: Nil

Game Review

Carlton met the Eagles for the first time since their Pre-Season Wizard Cup triumph. Many of the scribes would write that this was the game of two halves; I think it better to think of this as a game of contrasts - the super skilled midfield of the Eagles, compared to our midfield grouping of Stevens, Koutoufides and Camporeale.

Indeed it was a game of two halves. In the first quarter, the Blues surprised everyone by bursting out of the blocks and utilising an open forward line to great effect. Some straight kicking helped as well, plus the surprising output of Brett Johnson who would set up 3 goals. Although they tightened up in the second, the Blues would turn the corner still 10 points up.

And in the second half the Eagles midfield of Cousins and Judd and Kerr and Fletcher would just rip it away from us, delivering to forwards who couldn't touch it in the first quarter, and now suddenly ominous, or slotting goals themselves.

But the Eagles of 2005 were a sensational team to watch, and the Blues, well, we came last for good reason. To give up 15 goals and kick only one in a half tells the story of the difference in lists between 1st (Eagles finished up second after coming off the boil in the last month of the season) and 16th. In particular, the Eagles midfield would double the possessions of Carlton's brigade, with Heath Scotland leading our possession count with 17. In fact, Andrew Walker playing as a tagger on future Blue Judd, would almost pip him and never give up all day. Despite Walker's efforts, Judd still managed the 2 votes.

Other than Walker, the only other highlight was the performance of maligned full back Luke Livingston who would keep Quentin Lynch goalless and top our B&F votes for the game. It would seem as though others had given up, with Club leaders Camporeale (12 stats), Koutoufides (11 stats) and Stevens (16 stats) blown away.


B: 44 Andrew Carrazzo 4 Luke Livingston 32 Bret Thornton
HB: 43 Anthony Koutoufides (c) 15 David Teague 12 Matthew Lappin
C: 16 Scott Camporeale (vc) 10 Brett Johnson 20 Cory McGrath
HF: 30 Jarrad Waite 8 Lance Whitnall 22 Callum Chambers
F: 33 Ryan Houlihan 25 Brendan Fevola 21 Troy Longmuir
Ruck: 27 Chris Bryan 1 Andrew Walker 24 Nick Stevens
29 Heath Scotland, 18 Glen Bowyer, 28 Ian Prendergast, 36 Trent Sporn*
Coach: Denis Pagan
Emg: Justin Davies Digby Morrell Trent Sporn*
In: Luke Livingston, Troy Longmuir, David Teague, Jarrad Waite
Out: Jordan Bannister, Justin Davies, Eddie Betts, Kade Simpson*

-*late change Sporn for Simpson

Brownlow Votes

3: Dean Cox (WCE)
2: Chris Judd (WCE)
1: David Wirrpunda (WCE)

Best & Fairest Votes

Luke Livingston (21), Brendan Fevola (19), Matthew Lappin (16), Chris Bryan (15)

Round 13 | Round 15
Contributors to this page: Bombasheldon , molsey , BlueWorld , WillowBlue , kruddler and admin .
Page last modified on Sunday 09 of June, 2013 09:25:21 AEST by Bombasheldon.

Google Search

Random Image

1968 GF - Garry Crane: Carlton's best player.
1952 1st Semi - Keith Warburton marks strongly.

Online Users

304 online users