VFL Era
Ernie Walton 1897, 1900, 1903Peter Williams 1898-1899
Bill McNamara 1901-1902
Jim Flynn 1904
Mick Grace 1905
George Bruce 1906
Norman Clark 1907
Fred Jinks 1908-1909
Billy Payne 1910-1911
Billy Dick 1912
Jim Marchbank 1913
Harry Haughton 1914
Alf Baud 1915
Rod McGregor 1916-1917
Percy Daykin 1918
Paddy O'Brien 1919, 1922-23
Charlie Canet 1920
Jack Greenhill 1921
Stewart McLatchie 1924
Ray Brew 1925
Harry Toole 1925
Jim Watson 1926
Harold Carter 1927
Horrie Clover 1928-1930
Colin Martyn 1931
Frank Gill 1932
Tommy Downs 1933
Charlie Davey 1934
Creswell 'Mickey' Crisp 1935-1936
Jim Francis 1937-1940
Jack Carney 1941
Jim Mooring 1942-1943
Albert 'Mick' Price 1943-1944
Bob Green 1945
Rod McLean 1945-1946
Arthur Sanger 1946
Bert Deacon 1947-1950
Ken Hands 1951-1952
Fred Davies 1952
Jack Howell 1953-1954
Bill Milroy 1955
Laurie Kerr 1956-1958
John Chick 1959-1960
John Nicholls 1961-1962
Serge Silvagni 1963
Maurie Sankey 1964
John Nicholls 1965-1968
Wes Lofts 1969-1970
Robert Walls 1971-1976
Bruce Doull 1977
Alex Jesaulenko 1978
David McKay 1978
Peter Jones 1979
Mark Maclure 1980
Geoff Southby 1981-1983
Ken Hunter 1984-1986
Justin Madden 1987-1989
AFL Era
1990 - 1997; Craig Bradley1998 - 2001; Stephen Silvagni
2002 - 2003; Andrew McKay
2004 & 2006; Lance Whitnall
2004 - 2005; Scott Camporeale
2006; Matthew Lappin
2006; Nick Stevens
2007*
2008 - 2009; Nick Stevens
2014; Andrew Carrazzo, Kade Simpson
2020; Jacob Weitering
2022 - 2023; Sam Walsh and Jacob Weitering
NB In 2007 there did not appear to be a specific 'Vice Captain' role, instead replaced with a Leadership Group.