Carlton suffered a surprise 9 point loss to Fitzroy at the MCG.

Semi Final, 1917

Carlton 3.0 18 3.1 19 4.6 30 6.8 44
Fitzroy 2.4 16 4.9 33 5.11 41 6.17 53
Venue: MCG Date: Saturday September 1, 1917
Result: Loss by 9 points Umpire: A. Norden Crowd: 15,005
Goalkickers: B.Dick 3, V.Valentine 2, J.Shortill 1.
Best: L.Downs, C.Fisher, P.O'Brien, C.Hammond, B.Dick, P.Daykin, C.Canet, R.McGregor.
Reports: Four players were reported - see game review Injuries:

Game Review

Despite coming second overall, and having won the most recent battle against the Lions in Round 11, 1917, the Blues were bundled out of the finals race in this Semi Final. Fitzroy would go on to lose to the eventual Premiers, Collingwood, in the Grand Final.

Fitzroy got off to a good start in the first quarter, kicking 2 quick goals with the benefit of the wind. Carlton answered through first quarter goals to Shortill, Valentine and Dick. At the first break, the Blues looked good, their accurate kicking had given them a 2 point lead and they had the breeze in the second term.

Fitzroy held Carlton goalless in the second quarter, and had the better of the rest of the match. The Blues were always in with a sniff of victory due to the poor kicking of Fitzroy, but were never able to close the gap and didn't look like stealing the game. Lyle Downs was suspended for 10 games for attempting to kick Fitzroy's Frank Strawbridge, and Strawbridge was outed for 3 games for retaliating.

Mort Kiely was suspended for a scarcely-believable 24 matches for "abusive language towards a steward," whilst Billy Dick copped 3 games for "obscene language towards a steward"! Paddy O'Brien was outed for 2 matches for striking Fitzroy's Charlie Norris. These last three reports were all laid by Steward E Hough. (Stewards had been appointed to all VFL matches to monitor and report on rough play).


B: 3 Andy McDonald 8 Mort Keily 25 Frank Martin
HB: 9 Ted Brown 10 Paddy O'Brien 6 Steve Leehane
C: 12 Charlie Canet 11 Rod McGregor (vc) 21 William 'Mickey' Dunn
HF: 7 Charlie Fisher 23 Joe Shortill 2 Percy Daykin
F: 1 Billy Dick (c) 13 Vin Gardiner 4 Viv Valentine
Ruck: 19 Charlie Hammond 14 Ern Carter 28 Lyle Downs
Coach: Norman Clark


150 Games: Charlie Hammond
50 Games: Steve Leehane
Last Game: Vin Gardiner

Round 15 | 1918
Contributors to this page: WillowBlue , Bombasheldon , PatsFitztrick , camelboy , kkk , molsey , true_blue24 , steve and admin .
Page last modified on Tuesday 22 of December, 2015 09:20:03 AEDT by WillowBlue.

Google Search

Random Image

1906 Rnd 6, v Fitzroy Brunswick Street
2001 - Farewell: Dean Rice retires.

Online Users

437 online users