Carlton defeated the ladder leaders, Collingwood, by 8 points at Princes Park.

Round 8, 1918

Carlton 1.6 12 3.7 25 6.12 48 6.13 49
Collingwood 1.0 6 3.1 19 4.1 25 6.5 41
Venue: Princes Park Date: Saturday June 29, 1918
Result: Win by 8 points Umpire: Crowe Crowd: Small, see below
Goalkickers: E.Cowley 3, H.Haughton 2, J.Willis 1.
Reports: H.Haughton & R.McGregor. Injuries: Nil

Game Review

"No more unfavorable conditions could have prevailed. It was bitingly cold, with a driving rain. Consequently there was a very small attendance.
Congratuations were extended to Vin Gardiner, the former forward, and Mr. Reg Bray, a former treasurer of the Carlton club, who enlisted during the week." (Herald June 28)

The Blues avenged their loss to Collingwood in Round 1 with this 8 point victory. At the time, the Pies were sitting on top of the ladder, but after our victory, fell to second behind South Melbourne. Carlton were sitting in third with 5 wins from 8 games.

The game is perhaps best known for an umpiring controversy of the time. Gus Dobrigh of Collingwood was suspended for 4 games for striking Carlton’s Percy Daykin, but in addition, 2 Carlton players in Harry Haughton and Rod McGregor were suspended for 15 games and 5 games respectively for giving unsatisfactory evidence. Boundary Umpire Fox (supported by three Collingwood players) went to the tribunal after the Collingwood player had been suspended, and said he had told Haughton that he was going to report him, but didn’t report him after the game. The Carlton players denied knowledge of the report, but the tribunal accepted the Collingwood players and umpire version.

Collingwood's Bill Walton was also suspended (2 matches for striking Paddy O'Brien).

At the end of this round Carlton were in 3rd spot on the ladder with a percentage of 129.7.


B: 19 Fred Johnson 25 Frank Martin 6 Steve Leehane
HB: 9 Ted Brown 10 Paddy O'Brien 3 Andy McDonald
C: 12 Charlie Canet 11 Rod McGregor (c) 21 William Dunn
HF: 16 Jim Willis 5 Harry Haughton 2 Percy Daykin (vc)
F: 14 Leo Tasker 17 Ern Cowley 4 Viv Valentine
Ruck: 32 Jack Woolley 30 Dave Crone 7 Charlie Fisher
Coach: Norman Clark

Round 7 | Round 9
Contributors to this page: blueycarlton , Bombasheldon , camelboy , molsey , kkk , WillowBlue , true_blue24 and admin .
Page last modified on Friday 09 of February, 2018 13:18:08 AEDT by blueycarlton.

Google Search

Random Image

1982 GF - Ken Hunter flies for a mark.
1979 GF - David McKay & Robbert Klomp spoil Derek Shaw.

Online Users

219 online users