|Venue: Princes Park||Date: Saturday May 9, 1925|
|Result: Lose by 45 points||Umpire:||Crowd: 25,000|
|Goalkickers: H.Carter 2, M.Beasy 1, A.Charleston 1, V.Davis 1, P.Kennedy 1, H.Rumney 1.|
|Reports: Nil||Injuries: Nil|
Perhaps it was a sign of things to come, but Carlton sat in last spot with a percentage of 50.9% after this loss to the Same Old. Only two teams remained winless; the newly introduced team from Hawthorn, and the once-mighty Blues.
After this game Carlton's captain, Maurie Beasy and playing coach Paddy O'Brien both resigned their positions. Maurie was still living in Dunolly, and wasn't arriving home by train until lunchtime on Mondays, according to his son Doug Beasy.
At the end of this round Carlton were in 12th spot on the ladder with a percentage of 50.9.
|B:||26 Ray Brew (vc)||33 Jim Watson||4 Bill Koop|
|HB:||20 Ted Brewis||10 Paddy O'Brien (coach)||23 Ronnie Byrne|
|C:||2 Allan Leitch||13 Joe Russell||14 Harry Bell|
|HF:||27 Aub Charleston||1 Jack Way||32 Pat Kennedy|
|F:||17 Hope Evans||34 Victor Davis||15 Harold Rumney|
|Ruck:||11 Maurie Beasy (c)||22 Harry Toole||25 Harold Carter|
Ronnie Byrne, Hope Evans and Bill Koop
Last Game as Captain (his second): Maurie Beasy
Last Game: Joe Russell
Round 1 | Round 3