This was Carlton's first win over South Melbourne - by 17 points at Princes Park.

Round 1, 1898

Carlton 2.2 14 4.3 27 5.5 35 6.11 47
South Melbourne 1.2 8 1.7 13 2.10 22 3.12 30
Venue: Princes Park
Date: Saturday 14 May 1898
Result: Win by 17 points
Goalkickers: B.Walsh 3, C.Breese 2, W.O'Cock 1.
Umpire: Crapp
Injuries: J.Roberts (leg - during the first quarter), B.Casey

Game Review

It took more than 12 months, but Carlton eventually racked up its first premiership points against a team other than St Kilda when we knocked over the Bloods at Princes Park.

The margin should have been greater, but Carlton's forwards squandered some relatively easy shots on goal in the last quarter, and we registered 1 goal, 6 behinds for the term. Bobby Walsh and Wally Ocock were lively up front for the Blues, and picked up five goals between them.

"That Carlton have a powerful and clever ruck was demonstrated on Saturday, when Manchester, Morrison, O'Dea, and Pender on the ball beat South at their own game.
Jim Aitken, the Carlton captain, played under difficulties against South Melbourne. He had been suffering from influenza, and early in the week was in bed for two days."
(Herald May 20 p3)

"Carlton played a strong ruck, prominent in which was Manchester, a rapidly improving follower, while a pair of former North Melbourne players - O'Dea and Morrison - have been brought in to strengthen the team - in its play. Pender - who played a few matches with Geelong - shaped very well in the ruck. Roberts started the game, but was unfortunate in having his leg injured, and it is doubtful whether he will take further part in football. Four novices - Starkey, Brown, Ward and Barlow - all shaped well enough to merit further trials. Amongst the forwards Walsh and Breese were very good, the former getting three, and the latter two goals." (Argus May 16 p3)

At the end of this round Carlton were in 4th spot on the ladder with a percentage of 156.7.


B: Bill Sharkey George Warde Jim Lyons
HB: Fred Barlow Ernie Walton (vc) Jack Reekie
C: Jimmy Aitken (c) Peter Williams Bill Casey
HF: Jack Roberts Charlie Sweatman Bobby Walsh
F: Chic Breese Sam Chapman Wally O'Cock
Rucks: Len Morrison Jim Pender Tommy O'Day
Oscar Manchester
Rover: Charlie Brown
Coach: No coach and the captain directed the side
Note: 4 Rucks, 20 players on the ground and no interchange


In: B.Casey, J.Lyons, F.Barlow (ex South Melbourne), C.Brown (Ascot Vale), L.Morrison, T.O'Dea, J.Pender, B.Sharkeym (Fitzroy Jnrs), G.Warde (Melbourne Jnrs)
Out: B.Cameron, H.Dunne, B.Hannah, B.Woodhouse, H.Morgan, H.Crane, S.Reid, J.Goonan, B.Arnott


Debut: Charlie Brown (Ascot Vale), Len Morrison, Tommy O'Day, Jim Pender, Bill Sharkey (ex Fitzroy Juniors) , George Warde (Melbourne Juniors)
Debut and Only Game: Fred Barlow

The Herald Friday May 13 named 29 Carlton players from which the team was to be selected.
Aitken, Breese, Brown, Barlow, Casey, Chapman, Hall, Kerwick?, Manchester, Morrison?, O'Cock, O'Day, Pender, Roberts, Reekie, Sharkey, Sweetman, Walsh, Walton, Williams, Kenny?, Patterson, Lyons, Meadowcroft, Dunn?, Curtis, Warde, Armstrong, Cameron
Due to the poor quality of reproduction some names are unreadable.

1898 | Round 2
Contributors to this page: Jarusa , blueycarlton , Bombasheldon , PatsFitztrick , camelboy , molsey , WillowBlue and admin .
Page last modified on Thursday 26 of March, 2020 23:16:33 AEDT by Jarusa.

Online Users

88 online users
  • Bombasheldon