Blueseum - Online historical archive of the Carlton Football Club
Match Report
Semi Final · 1911
69vs48

9.15·6.12

ESSENDON won by 21
DateSaturday · 16 September 1911
VenueMCG
Attendance40,669
Margin21 pts
By the Quarter

Quarter-by-Quarter

TeamQ1Q2Q3Q4Final
Essendon
2.1
13
3.4
22
4.9
33
9.15
69
69
Carlton
2.6
18
4.7
31
5.11
41
6.12
48
48
The Match

Match Report

Umpire: J.Elder

Goalkickers: V.Gardiner 3, B.Dick 1, A.McDonald 1, V.Valentine 1.

Best: V.Valentine, G.Bruce, R.McGregor, T.Clancy, N.Clark, B.Dick, J.Wells, A.Wilson, A.McDonald, D.Harris, B.Payne.

Game Review

Essendon were now coached by ex-Carlton Coach Jack Worrall, who had led the Blues to three premierships between 1906 and 1908. While Carlton were in the lead all day until three quarter time, the Bombers kicked away in the last quarter scoring 5 goals to 1 to end Carlton's season. Essendon would go on to beat Collingwood in the Grand Final.

This match in notable as it was the first League game played in Victoria in which players wore numbers. Vin Gardiner, wearing No.13 became the first player to kick a goal whilst wearing a number during a match.
Note: Numbers were experimented with in the VFA days of the 1800's.

Team

B:

5 Dick Harris

6 Ernie Jamieson

19 Tommy Hughes

HB:

3 Norman Clark

2 Billy Payne (vc)

4 Arthur Ford

C:

9 Tom Clancy

8 Rod McGregor

7 George Bruce

HF:

10 Jim Marchbank

11 Billy Dick

12 Martin Gotz

F:

16 Jack Wells

13 Vin Gardiner

18 Andy McDonald

Ruck:

15 Archie Wilson

1 Fred Elliott (cc)

17 Viv Valentine

Coach:

Fred Elliott

62899.jpg


Arthur Ford (Carlton) relieving his goal in the first quarter


Carlton checked on the half forward lines in the first quarter (No. 13 Vin Gardiner?)

62900.jpg


Arthur Ford (Carlton) relieving his goal in the first quarter

62901.jpg


Vin Gardiner leading League goal kicker, with Fred Elliott, Ernie Jamieson (6) and mascot

62902.jpg





Billy Dick (Carlton) passing in the second quarter and Belcher (Essendon) marking

62903.jpg


An enlarged, grainy picture showing Vin Gardiner running into an open goal to boot one of his early majors
Photos Trove: Australasian September 23 (p36)

Milestones

Last game: Fred Elliott, Dick Harris and Tommy Hughes
Footy Fact: This match in notable as it was the first League game played in Victoria that players wore numbers.
Interesting Fact: This was the first times numbers were used by the League in a match in Victoria and Carlton used numbers 1 to 13 and 15 to 19 (Number 14 was allocated to Gordon Green but he didn’t play in this final). Including Round 17, 2018 Carlton has only used number 1 to 10 in the same match eleven times.
The Richmond Guardian Saturday 23 September (p3) 1911;
"Numbering of 'footballers is the best move made by the League for a long time, and was throughly appreciated by the crowd on Saturday."

By the Numbers

Player Statistics

Carlton

#PlayerKIHBDIMKGLBHGAIFMIUPBOTKRB1%FFFACPCMCLCGHOBR%P
11Billy DickBilly Dick----1------------------
13Vin GardinerVin Gardiner----3------------------
17Viv ValentineViv Valentine----1------------------
18Andy McDonaldAndy McDonald----1------------------
Team Total----6------------------
Team Average----1.5------------------

Last updated by Jamie Sanderson ·