Blueseum - Online historical archive of the Carlton Football Club
A Splice of History

Legends of the Fall - Carlton Style

By Michael OlsenBy Stephen Williamson10 February 2026#Blueseum · #A Splice of History
Legends of the Fall - Carlton Style

Published 2012

We remember the Premiership heroes; we salute the brave and injured; we respect the enduring champions of old. But do we honestly recognise the guys who played when the Mighty Blues were mere flotsam?

The Great Eras
Carlton Fans have flocked to see Carlton in some of our greater eras; our Triple Premiership era of 1906-1908; our immediate Post WW2 teams of the late 1940's, the 1960's, the 70's-80's, and again in the mid 1990's.

Glory or Pain?

Era

Won / Lost

Premierships

1897 - 1915

TBD

5

1916 - 1937

TBD

Nil

1938 - 1949

TBD

3

1950 - 1961

TBD

Nil

1962 - 1972

TBD

3

1973 - 1982

TBD

3

1983 - 1995

TBD

2

1996 - 2012

TBD

Nil

But in between these periods of success came some dark times, in fact, the post 1995 flag era is one of our darkest periods, particularly post 2001.

The Blues who tried
In these Dark Eras, Carlton continued to work towards a better time with different degrees of success.

Lowest Winning Ratio (>10 games)

Player

Games / Wins

Winning Ratio

Luke Livingston

46 – 9 wins

19.6%

Trent Sporn

50 – 10 wins

21.0%

Len Morrison

56 – 12 wins

22.3%

Pat Considine

48 – 11 wins

22.9%

Jordan Bannister

53 – 12 wins

23.6%

Bill Sharkey

47 – 11 wins

24.5%

Barnaby French

71 – 17 wins

25.4%

Bill Casey

61 – 15 wins

25.4%

Bobby Walsh

78 – 20 wins

26.3%

Ian Prendergast

65 – 18 wins

27.7%

Cory McGrath

50 – 13 wins

28.0%

Last updated by Jamie Sanderson ·