Brownlow Votes All Years

1924

Edward Greeves (Geel) - 7 votes
(1924–1930: 1 vote per game)

3 votes: Paddy O'Brien
2 votes: Maurie Beasy
1 vote: Stan Trebilco

1925

Colin Watson (St Kilda) - 9 votes

2 votes: Ray Brew
2 votes: Maurie Beasy
2 votes: Hedley Blackmore
1 vote: Stan Trebilco

1926

Ivor Warne-Smith (Melb) - 9 votes

3 votes: Alex Duncan
1 vote: Norm Collins
1 vote: Joe Kelly
1 vote: Bill Koop
1 vote: Jim Watson

1927

Syd Coventry (Coll) - 7 votes

6 votes: Alex Duncan (2nd)
2 votes: Fred Gilby
1 vote: Maurie Beasy
1 vote: Harold Carter
1 vote: Joe Kelly

1928

Ivor Warne-Smith (Melb) - 8 votes

1 vote: Ray Brew
1 vote: Horrie Clover
1 vote: Colin Martyn

1929

Albert Collier (Coll) - 6 votes

3 votes: Harry Vallence
2 votes: Joe Kelly
1 vote: Ray Brew
1 vote: Frank Gill
1 vote: Charlie Davey
1 vote: Colin Martyn

1930

Stan Judkins, Harry Collier & Allan Hopkins - 4 votes

2 votes: Joe Kelly
2 votes: Colin Martyn
1 vote: Vin Arthur
1 vote: Ansell Clarke
1 vote: Charlie Davey
1 vote: Fred Gilby
1 vote: Frank Gill
1 vote: Fred Williams

1931

Haydn Bunton (Fitzroy) - 26 votes
(First year of 3-2-1 voting)

11 votes: Colin Martyn
7 votes: Harry Vallence
5 votes: Charlie Davey
5 votes: Eric Huxtable
3 votes each: Tommy Downs, Alf Egan, Fred Gilby, Frank Gill, Joe Kelly, George Morrissey
Unspecified votes: Creswell 'Mickey' Crisp

1932

Haydn Bunton (Fitzroy) - 23 votes

9 votes: Creswell 'Mickey' Crisp
9 votes: Eric Huxtable
6 votes: Gordon Mackie
5 votes: Maurie Johnson
3 votes each: Fred Gilby, Frank Gill, Jack Green, Joe Kelly, Eric Little, Harry Vallence
2 votes: Ron Cooper
1 vote each: Charlie Davey, Colin Martyn, Leo Opray

1933

Wilfred Smallhorn (Fitzroy) - 18 votes

8 votes: Eric Huxtable
4 votes each: Creswell 'Mickey' Crisp, Charlie Davey
3 votes each: Horrie Bullen, Frank Gill, Joe Kelly
2 votes each: Ansell Clarke, Les Hughson, Maurie Johnson, Keith Shea

1934

Dick Reynolds (Essendon) - 19 votes

17 votes: Keith Shea (3rd)
9 votes: Ron Cooper
6 votes: Eric Huxtable
4 votes each: Ansell Clarke, Jim Francis
3 votes: Harry Vallence
2 votes: Frank Gill
1 vote each: Jack Cooper, Creswell 'Mickey' Crisp, Bob Green, Maurie Johnson, Eric Little

1935

Haydn Bunton (Fitzroy) - 25 votes

16 votes: Keith Shea
10 votes each: Jim Francis, Eric Huxtable
6 votes: Jack Hale
4 votes: Creswell 'Mickey' Crisp
3 votes: Clete Turner
2 votes each: Ron Cooper,

1936

Denis Ryan (Fitzroy) - 26 votes

13 votes: Keith Shea
5 votes each: Frank Anderson, Jack Carney, Jim Park
4 votes each: Jim Francis, Harry Vallence
3 votes each: Ansell Clarke, Ron Cooper, Charlie Davey, Jack Hale
2 votes: Creswell 'Mickey' Crisp
1 vote each: Fred Gilby, Gordon Mackie

1937

Dick Reynolds (Essendon) - 27 votes

16 votes: Keith Shea
12 votes: Jim Francis
5 votes: Jack Carney
4 votes: Frank Gill
3 votes each: Don McIntyre, Jack Wrout
2 votes each: Creswell 'Mickey' Crisp, Albert 'Mick' Price
1 vote each: Frank Anderson, Bert Butler, Ron Cooper

1938

Dick Reynolds (Essendon) - 18 votes

12 votes: Jim Park
8 votes: Creswell 'Mickey' Crisp
6 votes: Ron Cooper
5 votes each: Jack Carney, Frank Gill
3 votes each: Ken Baxter, Albert 'Mick' Price, Paul Schmidt, Harry Vallence, Jack Wrout
2 votes each: Frank Anderson, Jim Francis, Rod McLean
1 vote: Bob Chitty

1939

Marcus Whelan (Coll) - 23 votes

6 votes each: Ken Baxter, Frank Gill
5 votes: Frank Anderson
4 votes each: Jack Carney, Creswell 'Mickey' Crisp, Jim Francis
3 votes each: Bob Green, Don McIntyre
2 votes each: Ron Cooper, Jack Wrout
1 vote: Albert 'Mick' Price

1940

Des Fothergill & Herb Matthews - 32 votes

9 votes: Jim Park
7 votes: Jim Mooring
5 votes: Creswell 'Mickey' Crisp
4 votes each: Jack Hale, Jack Wrout
3 votes each: Jack Carney, Cyril Mann, Paul Schmidt, Jack Skinner
2 votes each: Ken Baxter, Rod McLean, Ron Savage
1 vote each: Frank Anderson, Jack Bennett, Gordon Cameron, Jim Francis, Charlie McInnes

1941

Norm Ware (Footscray) - 23 votes

14 votes: Bob Chitty
9 votes: Jim Mooring
8 votes: Jim Francis
7 votes: Creswell 'Mickey' Crisp
4 votes each: Arthur Sanger, Paul Schmidt
3 votes: Jack Skinner
2 votes: Ron Cooper
1 vote each: Frank Anderson, Frank Gill, Jack Hale, Jack Wrout

1942–1945

No Brownlow votes due to World War II

1946

Don Cordner (Melb.) - 20 votes

19 votes: Jack Howell (2nd)
17 votes: Bert Deacon
3 votes each: Arthur Sanger, Clinton Wines
2 votes each: Jack Conley, Jim Mooring
1 vote each: Ron Boys, Jim Clark, Ray Garby, Ollie Grieve, Doug Williams

1947

Bert Deacon (Carlton) - 23 votes

23 votes: Bert Deacon
11 votes: Ern Henfry
10 votes: Jack Howell
4 votes: Fred Stafford
3 votes: Ollie Grieve
2 votes each: Ritchie Green, Herb Turner
1 vote each: Jim Clark, Fred Fitzgibbon, Ken Hands

1948

Bill Morris (Richmond) - 24 votes

21 votes: Ollie Grieve (2nd)
11 votes: Bert Deacon
8 votes: Jack Howell
7 votes: Jim Clark
6 votes: Ern Henfry
1 vote each: Tom Simmons, Fred Stafford

1949

Ron Clegg (Sth. Melb) - 23 votes

13 votes: Ern Henfry
10 votes: Ritchie Green
8 votes: Jim Clark
6 votes: Ollie Grieve
5 votes: Jack Howell
3 votes each: Bert Deacon, Ray Garby, Arthur Hodgson
2 votes each: Jim Baird, Tom Simmons
1 vote each: Alan Streeter, Doug Williams

1950

Alan Ruthven (Fitzroy) - 39 votes

12 votes: Ollie Grieve
5 votes each: Jack Mills, Fred Stafford
4 votes each: Fred Davies, Arthur Hodgson
3 votes: Doug Williams
2 votes each: Jim Clark, Jack Howell
1 vote each: Jack Conley, Ritchie Green, Ern Henfry

1951

Bernie Smith (Geelong) - 23 votes

13 votes: Jim Clark
9 votes: Bert Deacon
7 votes: Ollie Grieve
4 votes: Ern Henfry
3 votes each: Jack Conley, Fred Davies, Arthur Hodgson, Jack Mills, Bill Milroy
2 votes each: Laurie Kerr,

1952

Roy Wright & Bill Hutchinson - 21 votes

10 votes: Ollie Grieve
9 votes: Jack Howell
5 votes each: Doug Beasy, Jack Spencer
4 votes: Laurie Kerr
3 votes each: Fred Davies, Vin English, Ern Henfry, Bill Milroy, Keith Warburton
2 votes: Jack Mills

1953

Bill Hutchinson (Essendon) - 26 votes

12 votes: Ken Hands
8 votes each: Vin English, Jack Howell
5 votes: Jack Mills
3 votes each: Bill Milroy, Ron Robertson, Keith Warburton
2 votes each: Doug Beasy, John Brown, Harry Dern
1 vote each: Laurie Kerr, Jack Spencer, Harry Sullivan

1954

Roy Wright (Richmond) - 29 votes

12 votes: John James
6 votes each: George Ferry, Keith Warburton
5 votes each: Bruce Comben, Ron Robertson
4 votes: Jack Howell
3 votes each: John Brown, Noel O'Brien, Peter Webster, Max Wenn
2 votes: Ken Hands
1 vote: Jack Mills

1955

Fred Goldsmith (Sth. Melb) - 21 votes

15 votes: John James
6 votes: Denis Zeunert
5 votes: Laurie Kerr
4 votes each: John Chick, Jack Mills
3 votes: Ron Robertson
2 votes each: Doug Beasy, Graham Donaldson, George Ferry
1 vote each: Harry Caspar, Noel O'Brien

1956

Peter Box (Footscray) - 22 votes

10 votes: John James
8 votes each: George Ferry, Peter Webster
6 votes: Laurie Kerr
4 votes each: Doug Beasy, Bruce Comben, Bill Milroy
3 votes each: John Chick, Ken Hands, Denis Zeunert
2 votes each: Kevin Bergin, Vin English, Jack Mills
1 vote: Graham Donaldson

1957

Brian Gleeson (St Kilda) - 24 votes

19 votes: John James (3rd)
8 votes each: Doug Beasy, Ken Hands
7 votes: Bruce Comben
4 votes: Denis Zeunert
3 votes: Peter Webster
2 votes each: John Chick, Kevin Clarke, Ross Ousley
1 vote each: Brian Buckley, John Nicholls

1958

Neil Roberts (St Kilda) - 24 votes

12 votes: John Benetti
9 votes: Graham Donaldson
5 votes each: Bruce Comben, John James
3 votes each: Doug Beasy, George Ferry, John Heathcote, Serge Silvagni
2 votes each: Peter Barry, Graham Gilchrist
1 vote each: John Chick, Berkley Cox,

1959

Verdun Howell (St. Kilda) - 20 votes

11 votes: Graham Donaldson
8 votes: John Heathcote
6 votes each: Leo Brereton, Bruce Comben, George Ferry, Laurie Kerr
5 votes each: John Chick, John Nicholls
3 votes each: Bill Arch, Serge Silvagni
2 votes each: Peter Barry, Bruce Williams
1 vote each: John James, Peter Webster

1960

John Schultz (Footscray) - 20 votes

12 votes: John James
11 votes: Graham Donaldson
5 votes: Denis Zeunert
4 votes: Bob Crowe
3 votes each: Bruce Comben, George Ferry, John Nicholls, Serge Silvagni
2 votes each: John Benetti, Leo Brereton
1 vote each: John Chick, Berkley Cox, Chris Pavlou, Maurie Sankey

1961

John James (Carlton) - 21 votes (Winner)

21 votes: John James
8 votes: Chris Pavlou
7 votes: John Nicholls
5 votes: Serge Silvagni
3 votes each: Bruce Comben, Graham Donaldson
2 votes each: Brian Buckley, Gordon Collis
1 vote each: Martin Cross, Bob Crowe, John Heathcote

1962

Alastair Lord (Geelong) - 28 votes

10 votes each: Peter Falconer, Bruce McMaster-Smith
7 votes each: Tom Carroll, John Nicholls
6 votes: Bob Crowe
5 votes: Gordon Collis
3 votes each: Berkley Cox, Serge Silvagni, Bruce Williams
2 votes each: John Benetti, Murray Kick, Maurie Sankey

1963

Bob Skilton (Sth. Melb.) - 20 votes

10 votes: Serge Silvagni
8 votes: John Comben
7 votes: John Gill
6 votes each: Maurie Sankey, Bruce Williams
3 votes: Tom Carroll
2 votes each: John Benetti, Dave Rogers, Cliff Stewart
1 vote each: Graeme Anderson, Trevor Best, Ian Collins, Berkley Cox, John Nicholls

1964

Gordon Collis (Carlton) - 27 votes (Winner)

27 votes: Gordon Collis
4 votes: Ian Collins
3 votes each: John Comben, John Gill, Bruce McMaster-Smith, John Nicholls
2 votes each: Berkley Cox, Adrian Gallagher, Tony Thiessen
1 vote each: Brian Buckley, John Goold, Ken Greenwood, Serge Silvagni

1965

Ian Stewart & Noel Teasdale - 20 votes

15 votes: John Nicholls
9 votes: Adrian Gallagher
6 votes: Ian Collins
5 votes each: Ron Barassi, John Goold
4 votes: Bryan Quirk
3 votes each: Garry Crane, Serge Silvagni, Cliff Stewart
2 votes: Kevin Hall
1 vote: Gordon Collis

1966

Ian Stewart (St. Kilda) - 21 votes

17 votes: John Nicholls (2nd)
11 votes: John Goold
5 votes: Cliff Stewart
3 votes each: Graeme Anderson, Ron Barassi, Barry Gill, Peter McLean, Jim Pleydell
2 votes each: Wes Lofts, Bryan Quirk
1 vote each: Garry Crane, Adrian Gallagher

1967

Ross Smith (St. Kilda) - 24 votes

15 votes: Alex Jesaulenko
7 votes each: John Goold, John Nicholls
6 votes each: Adrian Gallagher, Cliff Stewart
3 votes each: Ron Barassi, Gordon Collis, Peter Kerr
2 votes each: John Lloyd, Wes Lofts, Dennis Munari, Serge Silvagni
1 vote: Barry Gill

1968

Bob Skilton (Sth. Melb.) - 24 votes

17 votes: John Nicholls
10 votes: Alex Jesaulenko
6 votes: Brent Crosswell
5 votes each: John Goold, Serge Silvagni
4 votes each: Garry Crane, Brian Kekovich
3 votes: Ron Auchettl
2 votes each: Ian Collins, Kevin Hall, Peter Jones, Bryan Quirk
1 vote each: Ian Robertson, Cliff Stewart

1969

Kevin Murray (Fitzroy) - 19 votes

11 votes: John Nicholls
9 votes: Alex Jesaulenko
6 votes each: Garry Crane, Adrian Gallagher, Syd Jackson
5 votes: Serge Silvagni
4 votes each: John Goold, Peter Jones
3 votes each: Wes Lofts, Ian Robertson
2 votes each: Ian Collins,

1970

Peter Bedford (Sth. Melb.) - 25 votes

20 votes: Alex Jesaulenko (3rd)
7 votes: Kevin Hall
6 votes: Syd Jackson
5 votes: Ian Nicoll
4 votes: Ted Hopkins
3 votes each: Brent Crosswell, Adrian Gallagher, David McKay, Ian Robertson, Serge Silvagni, Vin Waite
2 votes each: Garry Crane, Wes Lofts, Bryan Quirk, Robert Walls
1 vote: Bert Thornley

1971

Ian Stewart (Richmond) - 21 votes

7 votes each: Adrian Gallagher, John Nicholls
6 votes: Geoff Southby
5 votes each: Bill Barrot, David McKay
4 votes each: Garry Crane, Robert Walls
3 votes each: Ian Collins, Brent Crosswell, Barry Gill, Syd Jackson, Chris Mitchell, Ian Robertson, Serge Silvagni, Vin Waite
1 vote: Bryan Quirk

1972

Len Thompson (Collingwood) - 25 votes

11 votes each: Alex Jesaulenko, Trevor Keogh
8 votes: Geoff Southby
7 votes: Brent Crosswell
5 votes each: Bruce Doull, Paul Hurst
4 votes: Robert Walls
3 votes each: Garry Crane, Adrian Gallagher, Syd Jackson, Andy Lukas, David McKay, Bryan Quirk, Ian Robertson
2 votes: Greg Kennedy
1 vote: Kevin Hall

1973

Keith Greig (Nth. Melb.) - 27 votes

17 votes: David McKay
11 votes: Garry Crane
10 votes: Peter Jones
8 votes: Geoff Southby
6 votes each: Alex Jesaulenko, Robert Walls
5 votes each: Barry Armstrong, Brent Crosswell
3 votes: Trevor Keogh
2 votes each: Greg Kennedy, Vin Waite
1 vote each: Rod Austin, Neil Chandler, David Dickson

1974

Keith Greig (Nth. Melb.) - 27 votes

8 votes each: Garry Crane, David McKay
6 votes: Rod Ashman
5 votes each: Barry Armstrong, Geoff Southby
4 votes: Alex Jesaulenko
3 votes each: Peter Jones, Vin Waite
2 votes each: Rod Austin, Craig Davis, Phil Pinnell
1 vote each: David Dickson, Bruce Doull, Trevor Keogh, Ian Robertson, Brian Walsh

1975

Gary Dempsey (Footscray) - 20 votes

18 votes: Alex Jesaulenko (3rd)
11 votes each: Rod Ashman, Mike Fitzpatrick
6 votes: Peter Jones
5 votes: David McKay
4 votes each: Mark Maclure, Geoff Southby
3 votes each: Barry Armstrong, Rod Austin
2 votes: Bruce Doull
1 vote: Greg Kennedy

1976

Graham Moss (Essendon) - 48 votes
(1976–1977: 12 votes max per game, 3-2-1 from each umpire)

21 votes: Rod Ashman
20 votes: Robert Walls
19 votes: Alex Jesaulenko
18 votes: Bruce Doull
15 votes each: Trevor Keogh, Tony Pickett
11 votes: Peter Jones
6 votes: Syd Jackson
5 votes each: Barry Armstrong, David McKay, Mark Maclure
3 votes: Ray Byrne
2 votes each: Phil Pinnell, Graeme Whitnall
1 vote each: Rod Galt, Danny Halloran, Kevin Heath, Geoff Southby, Greg Towns

1977

Graham Teasdale (Sth. Melb.) - 59 votes

34 votes: Bruce Doull
14 votes: Rod Ashman
13 votes: Geoff Southby
11 votes: Peter Jones
8 votes each: Rod Austin, Greg Towns
6 votes each: Alex Jesaulenko, Mark Maclure
5 votes each: Alan Mangels, John Tresize
4 votes each: Jim Buckley, Rod Galt, Robert Walls
3 votes each: Leigh McConnon, Graeme Whitnall
2 votes each: Peter Bedford, Ken Sheldon
1 vote each: Ray Byrne, Tony Pickett

1978

Malcolm Blight (Nth. Melb.) - 22 votes
(Returned to 6 votes max per game, 3-2-1)

12 votes: Denis Collins
10 votes each: Peter Jones, David McKay
8 votes: Bruce Doull
7 votes: Alex Jesaulenko
6 votes: Mark Maclure
5 votes each: Wayne Harmes, Geoff Southby
4 votes each: Barry Armstrong, Vin Catoggio, Greg Towns
3 votes: Rod Galt
2 votes each: Jim Buckley, Trevor Keogh

1979

Peter Moore (Collingwood) - 22 votes

13 votes each: Robbert Klomp, Mark Maclure
12 votes: Wayne Harmes
7 votes: Alex Marcou
6 votes each: Mike Fitzpatrick, Geoff Southby
5 votes each: Bruce Doull, Ken Sheldon
4 votes each: Alex Jesaulenko, Peter McConville
3 votes each: Denis Collins, Peter Francis, Trevor Keogh, Alan Mangels
2 votes: Peter Jones
1 vote each: Rod Ashman, Wayne Johnston

1980

Kelvin Templeton (Footscray) - 23 votes

12 votes: Val Perovic
11 votes: Greg Wells
7 votes: Phil Maylin
6 votes each: Vin Catoggio, Alex Marcou
5 votes each: Bruce Doull, Mark Maclure
4 votes each: Ken Sheldon, Geoff Southby
3 votes each: Rod Ashman, Rod Austin, Wayne Johnston, Robbert Klomp, David McKay, Alan Mangels
2 votes: Mike Fitzpatrick
1 vote each: Barry Armstrong, Des English

1981

Bernie Quinlan (Fitzroy) & Barry Round (Sth. Melb.) - 22 votes

21 votes: Rod Ashman (2nd)
12 votes: Ken Hunter
11 votes each: Peter Bosustow, Val Perovic
9 votes: Bruce Doull
8 votes: Mike Fitzpatrick
5 votes: Des English
4 votes each: David Glascott, Wayne Harmes
3 votes each: Alex Marcou, Greg Wells
2 votes each: Ken Sheldon, Geoff Southby
1 vote: Robbert Klomp

1982

Brian Wilson (Melb.) - 23 votes

13 votes: Val Perovic
8 votes each: Peter Bosustow, Jim Buckley, David Glascott, Wayne Harmes, Ken Hunter
6 votes: Phil Maylin
5 votes: Bruce Doull
4 votes each: Rod Ashman, Warren 'Wow' Jones
3 votes each: Ross Ditchburn, Alex Marcou
2 votes: Rod Austin

1983

Ross Glendinning (Nth. Melb.) - 24 votes

14 votes: Val Perovic
8 votes each: Wayne Harmes, Wayne Johnston
7 votes: Spiro Kourkoumelis
4 votes each: Peter Bosustow, David Glascott, Ken Hunter
3 votes: Jim Buckley
2 votes each: Bruce Doull, Justin Madden, Peter McConville, Paul Meldrum
1 vote each: Mark Buckley, Des English

1984

Peter Moore (Coll.) - 24 votes

12 votes each: Jim Buckley, Wayne Johnston
11 votes: Rod Ashman
9 votes: Spiro Kourkoumelis
7 votes: Bruce Doull
6 votes: Des English
3 votes each: Ken Hunter, Peter McConville, Paul Meldrum
2 votes each: Peter Dean, Fraser Murphy, Val Perovic, Warren Ralph, Geoff Southby
1 vote each: Wayne Blackwell, Justin Madden, Bruce Reid

1985

Brad Hardie (Footscray) - 22 votes

21 votes: Justin Madden (2nd)
14 votes: Tom Alvin
7 votes each: Mark Maclure, Paul Meldrum
5 votes: Rod Ashman
4 votes each: Wayne Harmes, Fraser Murphy, Stephen Silvagni
3 votes: Bruce Doull
2 votes each: Des English, Ken Hunter, David Rhys-Jones, Peter Rohde
1 vote each: Peter Dean, Spiro Kourkoumelis, Peter McConville

1986

Greg Williams (Syd) & Robert Dipierdomenico (Hawthorn) - 17 votes

12 votes each: Jon Dorotich, Wayne Harmes
10 votes: Paul Meldrum
9 votes each: Craig Bradley, Ken Hunter, Justin Madden

1986

Greg Williams (Syd) & Robert Dipierdomenico (Hawthorn) - 17 votes

12 votes each: Jon Dorotich, Wayne Harmes
10 votes: Paul Meldrum
9 votes each: Craig Bradley, Ken Hunter, Justin Madden
8 votes: Wayne Blackwell
6 votes: Tom Alvin
5 votes: Bernie Evans
4 votes: Bruce Doull
3 votes each: Peter Motley, David Rhys-Jones
2 votes: Mark Maclure
1 vote: Wayne Johnston

1987

John Platten (Hawthorn) & Tony Lockett (St. Kilda) - 20 votes

15 votes: Paul Meldrum (2nd)
14 votes each: Craig Bradley, Stephen Kernahan
12 votes: Mark Naley
9 votes: David Rhys-Jones
8 votes: Jon Dorotich
7 votes: Justin Madden
5 votes: Wayne Johnston
3 votes each: Richard Dennis, Shane Robertson
2 votes each: Tom Alvin, Peter Sartori
1 vote each: David Glascott, Peter Motley

1988

Gerard Healy (Melb.) - 20 votes

13 votes: Adrian Gleeson
12 votes: Wayne Johnston
9 votes: Stephen Silvagni
6 votes: Jon Dorotich
5 votes each: Wayne Blackwell, Justin Madden
4 votes each: Ken Hunter, Mark Naley
3 votes each: Stephen Kernahan, Fraser Murphy, David Rhys-Jones
2 votes each: Tom Alvin, Craig Bradley, Richard Dennis, Ian Herman, Paul Meldrum
1 vote each: Jim Buckley, Steve Da Rui, David Glascott

1989

Paul Couch (Geelong) - 22 votes

11 votes: Justin Madden
9 votes each: Mil Hanna, Stephen Kernahan
8 votes: Craig Bradley
4 votes: Mark Naley
3 votes each: Peter Dean, Adrian Gleeson, Simon Verbeek
2 votes each: Tom Alvin, Paul Meldrum, Luke O'Sullivan
1 vote each: Wayne Blackwell, Jon Dorotich, David Glascott

1990

Tony Liberatore (Footscray) - 18 votes

16 votes: Stephen Silvagni (3rd)
8 votes: Justin Madden
6 votes each: Adrian Bassett, Craig Bradley
5 votes: Paul Meldrum
4 votes: Stephen Kernahan
3 votes each: Dom Fotia, David Glascott, Mil Hanna, Simon Minton-Connell, Mark Naley
2 votes each: Tom Alvin, Ian Herman, Andrew Phillips
1 vote each: Adrian Gleeson, Glenn Hawker, David Kernahan, Luke O'Sullivan

1991

Jim Stynes (Melb.) - 25 votes

10 votes: Peter Dean
8 votes: Justin Madden
6 votes each: Craig Bradley, Mil Hanna
5 votes each: Stephen Kernahan, Stephen Silvagni
4 votes: Andrew Phillips
3 votes: Andrew Cavedon
1 vote each: Mark Arceri, Richard Dennis, Stephen Edgar, Adrian Gleeson, Michael James, Brett Ratten

1992

Scott Wynd (Footscray) - 20 votes

12 votes: Jon Dorotich
11 votes: Adrian Gleeson
8 votes each: Fraser Brown, Stephen Kernahan
7 votes: Justin Madden
6 votes each: Mil Hanna, Earl Spalding, Greg Williams
5 votes: Stephen Silvagni
4 votes each: Craig Bradley, Matthew Hogg
2 votes: Brett Sholl
1 vote each: Tom Alvin, Anthony Koutoufides

1993

Gavan Wanganeen (Essendon) - 18 votes

17 votes: Greg Williams (2nd)
11 votes: Justin Madden
8 votes: Stephen Kernahan
6 votes each: Craig Bradley, Adrian Gleeson, Stephen Silvagni
5 votes: Peter Dean
4 votes each: Mil Hanna, Michael Sexton
3 votes: Ang Christou
2 votes each: Brent Heaver, Andrew McKay, Earl Spalding
1 vote: Rohan Welsh

1994

Greg Williams (Carlton) - 30 votes (Winner)

30 votes: Greg Williams
12 votes: Justin Madden
6 votes each: Mil Hanna, Barry Mitchell, Stephen Silvagni
5 votes each: Ang Christou, Stephen Kernahan
4 votes: Craig Bradley
3 votes each: Peter Dean, Adrian Gleeson, Anthony Koutoufides, Andrew McKay
2 votes: Fraser Brown
1 vote each: James Cook, Matthew Hogg

1995

Paul Kelly (Sydney) - 21 votes

12 votes: Anthony Koutoufides
10 votes: Craig Bradley
9 votes: Matt Clape
8 votes each: Stephen Kernahan, Earl Spalding
7 votes each: Ang Christou, Mil Hanna
6 votes: Greg Williams
5 votes each: Fraser Brown, Scott Camporeale
4 votes each: Peter Dean, Brad Pearce
3 votes: Barry Mitchell
2 votes each: Justin Madden, Dean Rice, Michael Sexton
1 vote: Stephen Silvagni

1996

James Hird (Ess.) & Michael Voss (Brisbane) - 21 votes

12 votes each: Fraser Brown, Anthony Koutoufides
7 votes each: Brett Ratten, Greg Williams
6 votes each: Craig Bradley, Michael Sexton
5 votes each: Scott Camporeale, Adrian Hickmott, Stephen Silvagni
4 votes: Glenn Manton
3 votes each: Ang Christou, Justin Madden
2 votes: Brent Heaver
1 vote each: Matt Clape, Stephen Kernahan, Dean Rice

1997

Robert Harvey (St. Kilda) - 26 votes

15 votes: Craig Bradley
12 votes: Brett Ratten
6 votes: Anthony Koutoufides
5 votes: Stephen Silvagni
3 votes each: Matthew Allan, Luke O'Sullivan, Greg Williams
2 votes each: Adrian Hickmott, Darren Hulme, Glenn Manton, Andrew McKay, Michael Sexton
1 vote each: Aaron Hamill, Justin Murphy, Dean Rice

1998

Robert Harvey (St. Kilda) - 32 votes

18 votes: Fraser Brown
10 votes: Craig Bradley
8 votes: Lance Whitnall
7 votes: Scott Camporeale
4 votes: Matthew Allan
3 votes each: Justin Murphy, Brett Ratten
2 votes each: Andrew McKay, Brad Pearce, Stephen Silvagni
1 vote each: Aaron Hamill, Darren Hulme, Glenn Manton, Dean Rice

1999

Shane Crawford (Hawthorn) - 28 votes

20 votes: Matthew Allan (3rd)
18 votes: Craig Bradley
9 votes: Andrew McKay
6 votes: Anthony Koutoufides
5 votes: Simon Beaumont
4 votes each: Scott Camporeale, Brett Ratten
3 votes each: Fraser Brown, Justin Murphy
2 votes each: Michael Sexton, Stephen Silvagni
1 vote each: Brett Backwell, Kris Massie

2000

Shane Woewodin (Melb.) - 24 votes

19 votes: Anthony Koutoufides (4th)
18 votes: Brett Ratten
12 votes: Craig Bradley
10 votes: Scott Camporeale
9 votes: Lance Whitnall
8 votes: Andrew McKay
6 votes: Matthew Allan
4 votes: Aaron Hamill
3 votes: Trent Hotton
2 votes each: Adrian Hickmott, Mark Porter
1 vote each: Simon Beaumont, Matthew Lappin

2001

Jason Akermanis (Brisbane) - 23 votes

10 votes each: Craig Bradley, Adrian Hickmott, Darren Hulme
9 votes: Andrew McKay
8 votes each: Anthony Koutoufides, Brett Ratten
7 votes: Matthew Lappin
5 votes each: Scott Camporeale, Mark Porter
3 votes: Jim Plunkett
2 votes each: Stephen Silvagni, Lance Whitnall
1 vote each: Anthony Franchina, Ryan Houlihan

2002

Simon Black (Brisbane) - 25 votes

5 votes each: Corey McKernan, Justin Murphy
4 votes each: Craig Bradley, Scott Camporeale
3 votes each: Matthew Lappin, Lance Whitnall
2 votes each: Andrew McKay, Trent Sporn
1 vote each: Simon Beaumont, Sam Cranage, Simon Fletcher

2003

Mark Ricciuto (Adel.), Nathan Buckley (Coll.), Adam Goodes (Syd.) - 22 votes

6 votes: Corey McKernan
5 votes: Anthony Koutoufides
4 votes each: Darren Hulme, Andrew McKay
3 votes each: Brendan Fevola, Ryan Houlihan
2 votes: Justin Murphy

2004

Chris Judd (W. Coast) - 30 votes

9 votes each: Scott Camporeale, Brendan Fevola, Matthew Lappin, Heath Scotland
7 votes each: Nick Stevens, David Teague
5 votes: Anthony Koutoufides
2 votes: Jordan Bannister
1 vote each: Ryan Houlihan, Brett Johnson, Andrew Walker

2005

Ben Cousins (W. Coast) - 20 votes

11 votes: Nick Stevens
5 votes each: Anthony Koutoufides, Jarrad Waite, Lance Whitnall
3 votes: Adam Bentick
1 vote each: Brendan Fevola, Heath Scotland, David Teague

2006

Adam Goodes (Sydney) - 26 votes

10 votes: Heath Scotland
9 votes: Brendan Fevola
8 votes: Nick Stevens
5 votes: Lance Whitnall
3 votes: Andrew Walker
2 votes each: Adam Bentick, Luke Blackwell, Marc Murphy, Kade Simpson
1 vote each: Barnaby French, Ryan Houlihan, Jarrad Waite

2007

Jimmy Bartel (Geelong) - 29 votes

12 votes: Heath Scotland
11 votes: Andrew Carrazzo
4 votes: Jarrad Waite
3 votes each: Brendan Fevola, Kade Simpson, Nick Stevens
2 votes: Andrew Walker
1 vote: Adam Bentick

2008

Adam Cooney (Foots) - 24 votes

16 votes: Chris Judd
11 votes each: Brendan Fevola, Marc Murphy
10 votes: Nick Stevens*
7 votes: Bryce Gibbs
5 votes: Jarrad Waite
2 votes each: Heath Scotland, Simon Wiggins*
1 vote each: Adam Bentick, Andrew Carrazzo, Matthew Kreuzer

2009

Gary Ablett (Geel) - 30 votes

22 votes: Chris Judd (2nd)
15 votes each: Bryce Gibbs, Marc Murphy
11 votes: Brendan Fevola
5 votes: Kade Simpson
2 votes each: Eddie Betts, Nick Stevens, Bret Thornton
1 vote each: Richard Hadley, Matthew Kreuzer, Setanta Ó hAilpín, Jarrad Waite

2010

Chris Judd (Carlton) - 30 votes (Winner)

30 votes: Chris Judd
9 votes: Kade Simpson
6 votes each: Bryce Gibbs, Heath Scotland
5 votes: Marc Murphy
4 votes: Jeff Garlett
3 votes: Eddie Betts
2 votes each: Andrew Carrazzo, Lachie Henderson
1 vote each: Matthew Kreuzer, Setanta Ó hAilpín, Jordan Russell

2011

Dane Swan (Coll) - 34 votes

23 votes: Chris Judd
19 votes: Marc Murphy
12 votes: Bryce Gibbs
9 votes: Mitch Robinson
8 votes: Heath Scotland
5 votes each: Kade Simpson, Andrew Walker
4 votes: Eddie Betts
3 votes: Matthew Kreuzer
2 votes: Nick Duigan
1 vote each: Robert Warnock, Chris Yarran

2012

Jobe Watson (Ess) - 30 votes

12 votes: Chris Judd
11 votes: Marc Murphy
10 votes: Brock McLean
9 votes: Heath Scotland
6 votes each: Mitch Robinson, Kade Simpson
3 votes each: Bryce Gibbs, Shaun Hampson, Matthew Kreuzer, Jarrad Waite
2 votes each: Andrew Carrazzo, Andrew Collins, David Ellard, Chris Yarran
1 vote each: Eddie Betts, Andrew Walker

2013

Gary Ablett (GC) - 28 votes

11 votes: Andrew Walker
10 votes: Marc Murphy
9 votes: Kade Simpson
7 votes each: Brock McLean, Jarrad Waite
6 votes: Matthew Kreuzer
5 votes: Chris Judd
4 votes: Lachie Henderson
3 votes each: Jeff Garlett, Bryce Gibbs, Chris Yarran
2 votes: Mitch Robinson
1 vote: Kane Lucas