Carlton lost to Richmond by 53 points - MCG. The second successive year the Blues had met the Tigers in a Semi Final and lost.

Semi Final, 1928

Venue: MCGDate: Saturday September 8, 1928
Result: Lose by 53 pointsUmpire: McMurrayCrowd: 66,381*
Goalkickers: G.Gough 4, H.Clover 3, H.Vallence 1, H.Dunn 1.
Best: H.Clover, G.Gough, J.Kelly, C.Martyn, F.Gilby, T.Brewis, H.Vallence.
Reports: T.Downs (Carlton - suspended for 12 weeks), Geddes (Richmond - suspended for 8 weeks).
Injuries: M.Johnson, A.Duncan, T.Downs & J.Kelly.

Game Review

In continuing from their recent history of spiteful clashes (see Round 17 of 1927) Carlton and Richmond would again have players reported in a game between the two clubs. Richmond's pace was too much for the Blues, and the game was never a contest, the Tigers running out easy 53 point winners.

The Blues who finished 4th played against the Tigers who finished 2nd, the other semi final pitted the Magpies (1st) against the Demons (3rd).

.*Reported in the Maitland Weekly Mercury as the largest crowd to attended a football match in Victoria.
Note: Two players, Fred Gilby and Jim Watson are still wearing the 1910 - 1926 monogramme.

Back Row: L-R; Maurie Connell, Horrie Clover, Allan Skehan, Alex Duncan, Ted Brewis, Harry Vallence, Frank Donoghue, Bert Everett
Centre Row: Colin Martyn, Ray Brew, Les Johnson, Joe Kelly
Front Row: Maurie Johnson, Fred Gilby, Tommy Downs, Harvey Dunn, George Gough, Jim Watson.
If anyone disagrees with the way these names have been placed, please contact Blueseum https://www.blueseum.org/tiki-contact.php


B: 26 Ray Brew (cc) 33 Jim Watson 20 Ted Brewis
HB: 18 Frank Donoghue 32 Alex Duncan 6 Fred Gilby
C: 7 Joe Kelly 2 Colin Martyn 9 Bert Everett
HF: 5 Les Johnson 1 Horrie Clover (vc) 15 Maurie Johnson
F: 22 Harry Vallence 14 George Gough 16 Harvey Dunn
Ruck: 29 Maurie Connell 12 Allan Skehan 28 Tommy Downs
Coach: Ray Brew


Last Game: Ted Brewis, Frank Donoghue, George Gough & Les Johnson

Round 18 | 1929
Contributors to this page: blueycarlton , Jarusa , Bombasheldon , PatsFitztrick , molsey , timmyd , WillowBlue , kkk , camelboy , steve and admin .
Page last modified on Thursday 20 of February, 2020 14:56:43 AEDT by blueycarlton.

Online Users

69 online users