Carlton 19.20.134 def St Kilda 15.14.104 - also known as Winmar's Meltdown

Round 20, 1998

St Kilda2.4166.84410.147415.14104
Venue: M.C.G.
Date: Sunday August 16, 1998 Result: Win by 30 points
Umpires: Dore, Hanley, MalcomeCrowd: 42,120
Goalkickers: S.Silvagni 5, A.White 3, L.Whitnall, B.Ratten, F.Brown 2, M.Allan, S.Camporeale, A.Franchina, G.Manton, D.Rice 1.
Best: F.Brown, C.Bradley, M.Allan, A.McKay, S.Silvagni, S.Camporeale, B.Ratten.
Reports: Injuries:

Game Review

This game would be long remembered as the game where Anthony Franchina (in his first game back from a 2 week suspension) would take on Saint Nicky Winmar and cause him to lose his cool. Stephen Silvagni would also kick 5 goals (the final margin) and would be the difference between the 2 teams. Fraser Brown picked up a career-high 42 disposals and picked up the 3 Brownlow votes. The Blues were off target in the first quarter against St Kilda kicking seven behinds before Fraser Brown kicked the Blues first goal of the game.


B: 23 Dean Rice 22 Glenn Manton 26 John Hynes
HB: 5 Andrew McKay 43 Anthony Koutoufides 3 Kris Massie
C: 14 Michael Sexton 18 Justin Murphy 16 Scott Camporeale
HF: 45 Anthony Franchina 8 Lance Whitnall 21 Craig Bradley (c)
F: 29 Simon Beaumont 1 Stephen Silvagni (vc) 34 Ron De Iulio
Ruck: 24 Matthew Allan 20 Fraser Brown 7 Brett Ratten
30 Adam White, 11 Mark Porter, 35 Peter Dean, 33 Matthew Hogg
Coach: David Parkin
Emg: Jacob Anstey Darren Hulme Damian Lang
In: Anthony Franchina Anthony Koutoufides
Out: Damien Lock (groin) Jacob Anstey (final)


Rising Star Nominees: Kris Massie

Brownlow Votes

3: Fraser Brown (CARL)
2: Craig Bradley (CARL)
1: Glenn Manton (CARL)

Round 19 | Round 21
Contributors to this page: Bombasheldon , molsey , true_blue24 , BlueWorld , WillowBlue , kruddler and admin .
Page last modified on Saturday 15 of June, 2013 22:30:13 AEST by Bombasheldon.

Online Users

145 online users