1919 - J. Gordon
1920 -
1921 -
1922 -
1923 -
1924 -
1925 - Jimmy Goonan
1926 - Jimmy Goonan captain and coach
1927 - Jimmy Goonan
1928 - Jimmy Goonan
1929 - Jimmy Goonan
1930 - Jim Robertson
1931 - Jimmy Goonan
1932 - Jimmy Goonan
1933 - Colin Martyn
1934 - Jimmy Goonan
1935 - Jim Crowe
1936 - Charlie Hardy
1937 - Charlie Hardy (also coach of the third eighteen, which was a junior team, in 1939 it was the Fawkner club.)
1938 - Charlie Hardy
1939 - Charlie Hardy / Alan Geddes. Hardy (also he thirds coach), resigned due employment pressure in May. Geddes took over his duties.
1940 - Charlie Canet
1941 -
1942 - Harry 'Soapy' Vallence, Captain & Coach.
1943 -
1951 - Albert 'Mick' Price
1952 - Albert 'Mick' Price
1953 - Albert 'Mick' Price
1954 - Albert 'Mick' Price
1955 - Albert 'Mick' Price
1956 - Albert 'Mick' Price
1957 - Jack Carney
1958 -
1959 -
1960 -
1961 -
1962 - Jack Carney
1963 - Jack Carney
1964 - Jack Carney
1965 - Jack Carney
1966 - Jack Carney
1967 - Graham Donaldson
1968 - Graham Donaldson
1969 - Graham Donaldson
1970 - Graham Donaldson
1971 - Keith McKenzie
1972 - Keith McKenzie
1973 - Keith McKenzie
1974 - Keith McKenzie
1975 - Keith McKenzie
1976 - Ian Collins (temporary - due to the promotion of Ian Thorougood to senior coach). During the season, Hugh Mitchell took over.
1977 - Hugh Mitchell
1978 - Serge Silvagni
1979 - Serge Silvagni
1980 - Serge Silvagni
1981 - Serge Silvagni
1982 - Bryan Quirk
1983 - Bryan Quirk
1984 - Colin Kinnear
1985 - Colin Kinnear
1986 - Colin Kinnear
1987 - Colin Kinnear
1988 - Colin Kinnear
1989 - Rod Ashman
1990 - Rod Ashman
1991 - Rod Ashman
1992 - Rod Ashman
1993 - Rod Ashman
1994 - Rod Ashman
1995 - Ken Judge
1996 - Wayne Brittain
1997 - Wayne Brittain
1998 - Wayne Brittain
1999 - Wayne Brittain
2000 - Ross Lyon Note: from the 2000 season onwards, the Reserves competition was resurrected as the VFL (Victorian Football League) following its merger with the VFA (Victorian Football Association).
2001 - Ross Lyon
2002 - Ross Lyon
1920 -
1921 -
1922 -
1923 -
1924 -
1925 - Jimmy Goonan
1926 - Jimmy Goonan captain and coach
1927 - Jimmy Goonan
1928 - Jimmy Goonan
1929 - Jimmy Goonan
1930 - Jim Robertson
1931 - Jimmy Goonan
1932 - Jimmy Goonan
1933 - Colin Martyn
1934 - Jimmy Goonan
1935 - Jim Crowe
1936 - Charlie Hardy
1937 - Charlie Hardy (also coach of the third eighteen, which was a junior team, in 1939 it was the Fawkner club.)
1938 - Charlie Hardy
1939 - Charlie Hardy / Alan Geddes. Hardy (also he thirds coach), resigned due employment pressure in May. Geddes took over his duties.
1940 - Charlie Canet
1941 -
1942 - Harry 'Soapy' Vallence, Captain & Coach.
1943 -
1951 - Albert 'Mick' Price
1952 - Albert 'Mick' Price
1953 - Albert 'Mick' Price
1954 - Albert 'Mick' Price
1955 - Albert 'Mick' Price
1956 - Albert 'Mick' Price
1957 - Jack Carney
1958 -
1959 -
1960 -
1961 -
1962 - Jack Carney
1963 - Jack Carney
1964 - Jack Carney
1965 - Jack Carney
1966 - Jack Carney
1967 - Graham Donaldson
1968 - Graham Donaldson
1969 - Graham Donaldson
1970 - Graham Donaldson
1971 - Keith McKenzie
1972 - Keith McKenzie
1973 - Keith McKenzie
1974 - Keith McKenzie
1975 - Keith McKenzie
1976 - Ian Collins (temporary - due to the promotion of Ian Thorougood to senior coach). During the season, Hugh Mitchell took over.
1977 - Hugh Mitchell
1978 - Serge Silvagni
1979 - Serge Silvagni
1980 - Serge Silvagni
1981 - Serge Silvagni
1982 - Bryan Quirk
1983 - Bryan Quirk
1984 - Colin Kinnear
1985 - Colin Kinnear
1986 - Colin Kinnear
1987 - Colin Kinnear
1988 - Colin Kinnear
1989 - Rod Ashman
1990 - Rod Ashman
1991 - Rod Ashman
1992 - Rod Ashman
1993 - Rod Ashman
1994 - Rod Ashman
1995 - Ken Judge
1996 - Wayne Brittain
1997 - Wayne Brittain
1998 - Wayne Brittain
1999 - Wayne Brittain
2000 - Ross Lyon Note: from the 2000 season onwards, the Reserves competition was resurrected as the VFL (Victorian Football League) following its merger with the VFA (Victorian Football Association).
2001 - Ross Lyon
2002 - Ross Lyon